| All-ODAC Selections | ||||
| Tina Phillips | 1983 (2nd) | |||
| Mary Beth Harvey | 1984 (1st) | |||
| Lesley Secrist | 1984-85 (2nd) | |||
| Vickie Zimmerman | 1985-86 (1st) | |||
| Sara McCloskey | 1986 (1st) | |||
| Charimane Martin | 1987 (2nd) | |||
| Alice Apperson | 1987 (2nd), 1988-89 (1st) | |||
| Tracey Driscoll | 1988 (2nd), 1989 (1st) | |||
| Karen Jenkins | 1990-91 (1st) | |||
| Debbie Jones | 1990 (1st), 1991 (2nd) | |||
| Donna Cogar | 1990 (2nd), 1992 (1st) | |||
| Jennifer Jones | 1991 (1st), 1992 (2nd) | |||
| Amy Saunders | 1992-93 (2nd) | |||
| Debbie Puch | 1993 (1st) | |||
| Kristie Workman | 1994 (1st) | |||
| Kay Caldwell | 1994 (1st) | |||
| Crystal Wilson | 1994 (2nd), 1995 (1st) | |||
| Lori Boyd | 1995 (HM), 1996 (2nd) | |||
| Marcee Hufton | 1995-96 (1st) | |||
| Amy Athey | 1995-96 (HM), 1997 (1st) | |||
| Suzanne Moore | 1997 (2nd) | |||
| Ashley McCallum | 1997 (HM) | |||
| Toree Morris | 1998 (HM) | |||
| Cheryl Rhodes | 1998 (HM), 1999 (2nd) | |||
| Carrie McConnell | 1999-2000 (2nd) | |||
| Crystal Barrett | 2000-02 (2nd), 2001 (1st) | |||
| Suzanne Webb | 2000-01 (HM) | |||
| Katrina Williams | 2001 (2nd), 2002-03 (1st) | |||
| Chandra Forrester | 2004 (HM) | |||
| Erin Hanson | 2005 (HM), 2006-08 (1st) | |||
| Caitlyn Long | 2008 (HM), 2009-10 (1st) | |||
| Torri Bridge | 2008 (HM) | |||
| Jaleesa Osborne | 2009 (2nd), 2010 (1st) | |||
| Jordan Gholson | 2009 (HM), 2010 (1st), 2011 (2nd) | |||
| Nicci Moats | 2011 (1st) | |||
| Paxton Gwin | 2012 (HM), 2013 (1st), 2014 (1st) | |||
| Laurel Hankins | 2013-14 (3rd) | |||
| Cary Beahm | 2015-16 (2nd), 17 (1st) | |||
| ODAC Player of the Year | ||||
| Vickie Zimmerman | 1985 | |||
| Alice Apperson | 1988-89 | |||
| Karen Jenkins | 1991 | |||
| Donna Cogar | 1992 | |||
| Amy Athey | 1997 | |||
| Katrina Williams | 2003 | |||
| Erin Hanson | 2007 | |||
| Paxton Gwin | 2013-14 | |||
| ODAC Rookie of the Year | ||||
| Erin Hanson | 2005 | |||
| D3Hoops.com National Team of the Week | ||||
| Katrina Williams | 2/11/2003 | |||
| VaSID All-State Team | ||||
| Diann Rader | 1971 | |||
| Leonda Hudson | 1971-74 | |||
| Joan Aichele | 1974 | NCAA Div. III All-Americans | ||
| Susan Highfill | 1976-79 | Leonda Hudson | 1974 | |
| Barb Reahl | 1979-80 | Susan Highfill | 1978-79 | |
| Ann Harwood | 1980-82 | Ann Harwood | 1983 | |
| Amy Athey | 1997 (1st) | Mary Beth Harvey | 1984 | |
| Carrie McConnell | 2000 | Vickie Zimmerman | 1985-86 | |
| Crystal Barrett | 2000-02 (HM) | Alice Apperson | 1989 | |
| Katrina Williams | 2002, 03 (2nd) | Karen Jenkins | 1991 | |
| Erin Hanson | 2008 (2nd) | Donna Cogar | 1992 | |
| Caitlyn Long | 2009 (HM), 2010(1st) | Crystal Wilson | 1995 | |
| Nicci Moats | 2011 (1st) | Marcee Hufton | 1996 | |
| Cary Beahm | 2015-16 (2nd), 17 (3rd) | Amy Athey | 1997 | |
| Katrina Williams | 2003 | |||
| GTE Dist. 3 All-Academic Team | Erin Hanson | 2007 | ||
| Cary Beahm | 2017 | |||
| Amy Athey | 1997 (2nd) | |||
| Cary Beahm | 2017 (1st) | VaSID Academic All-State | ||
| Va State All-Tournament | Nancy Cottrell | 1985 | ||
| Ann Harwood | 1981 | |||
| Carol Peschel | 1981 | Academic All-America | ||
| Cary Beahm | 2017 | |||
| VaSID State Coach of the Year | ||||
| Susan Dunagan | 2000 | ODAC Scholar Athlete of the Year | ||
| Cary Beahm | 2017 | |||
| NCAA Div. III All-South Region | ||||
| Ann Harwood | 1983 | |||
| Mary Beth Harvey | 1984 | |||
| Vickie Zimmerman | 1985-86 | |||
| Alice Apperson | 1988-89 | |||
| Karen Jenkins | 1990-91 | |||